PE is Overrated
Posted in Children fitness, exercise on May 13th, 2009 by adminA new study has come out in showing that exercise in school is not all that it’s cracked up to be. Researchers studied three schools focusing on the amount of PE the students got each day. The kids at the fancy, private school had much more PE and overall physical activity before the end of the school day than the other two schools. But, interestingly, the researchers determined that the increase of PE or other physical outlet at school made no difference quantitatively in children’s total daily physical activity level.
The findings determined that students from all three schools got about the same amount of physical activity and intensity level over the course of an entire day regardless of whether there were additional structured periods of exercise at school. The idea being that if you as a student were very active during the school day, then when you got home you were more likely to take it easy. Conversely, if you sat at a desk all day, you would be playing outside or riding your bike after school to burn off the excess energy. Researchers said the key was to focus on the big picture of the entire day of activity, rather than look at what happens before the final bell rings at school.
The timing of this study seems awfully coincidental to me in these economic times of major budget cuts in schools. Recess and PE in schools across the country are becoming a distant memory. How convenient that science now says “Guess what, PE doesn’t matter anyway.” I respectfully disagree.
In this day and age, when children are popping ritalin like candy, it is an injustice to say that barely existent exercise in our schools could possibly be beneficial to the health and welfare of our children. In fact, studies have shown just the opposite. Intense exercise is especially helpful to children with ADHD in helping them stay focused.
The premise of looking at exercise as a whole entity rather than a segment of a day, is also flawed in my book. It sounds good to say that children will run home to engage in physical activity if they were sedentary all day, but the truth is children today have no problem being sedentary 24 hours a day. The primal urge to exercise is lost on this video game generation because they have never developed the habit of vigorously exercising every day. Call it me, but the lack of regular PE class in school can’t be helping in this regard.
In a perfect world of schools valuing the mental, physical, and emotional health of its students as much as the academic health, an hour of PE would be mandatory for all students kindergarten through 12th grade. PE, if done well, is so much more than releasing pent up energy. It establishes the lifelong habit of daily physical activity, teaches you skills to improve your game, and challenges your body physically. PE should, at a minimum, be the base line of physical activity for children of all ages. Whatever happens after 3:00 is just value added. In this time of alarming childhood obesity rates, it seems irresponsible to justify the absence of physical education in our schools as scientifically irrelevant. Nothing is more relevant for our future than the physical health and well-being of our nation’s children.
